ARLINGTON, VA — For the first time since Logan Thompson arrived in DC, the Washington Capitals have a goaltending problem.
Thompson, arguably the team’s best player over the last two seasons, has looked little like his former self this month. In seven starts since November 1, Thompson has allowed an average of 3.4 goals per game for just a .841 save percentage, giving up goals on opponents’ first shot of the game three times in under three weeks. Head coach Spencer Carbery pulled Thompson just once in his first 110 games for Washington; he’s now done so twice in six games.
As the Capitals look to snap Thompson out of his funk, they have two options. They could opt to keep playing Thompson, getting him back on the horse as soon as possible. Or they could start Charlie Lindgren, giving Thompson time to reset before going back in the net.
Carbery isn’t yet sure which path the team will take.
“We haven’t made a decision on what’s going to go on for tomorrow night,” Carbery said. “There’s some times where you just want to let a guy play through some struggles, and then there’s sometimes where you’d like him to take a step back.
“Both can be utilized and both are appropriate at given times, and that’s just up to (goaltending coach) Scotty Murray, Logan, myself, and making the best decision possible.”
The pros and cons of each approach go beyond a single game. When Washington has found success in recent years, Thompson is a big part of the reason why: his league-leading goals saved above expected last season (plus-29.3, per MoneyPuck) meant he could compensate when the skaters in front of him faltered. Without that elite goaltending, the Capitals’ defensive failures have only gotten more glaring, and getting it back long-term matters more than any one win or loss.
| Season | Record | GAA | Save % | GSAx per 60* |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2025-26 | 31-21-6 | 2.44 | 0.912 | +0.51 |
| 2026-27 | 7-6-0 | 3.42 | 0.878 | -0.22 |
Thompson may not have personally experienced a rut like this in DC, but Carbery noted that it’s hardly unusual for goaltenders.
“Just like the best goalies on the planet — which I put [Thompson] in that group — there’s highs and lows and ups and downs,” Carbery said. “He’s fighting like hell to help our team and be the reason why we win games, and he’s no different than anybody else on our team. We all have to do more, staff included, and put our heads down.”
Goaltending is a notoriously mental position, often an isolating one. But Thompson is hardly alone in his slump this year — Carbery acknowledged that people getting in their heads or “gripping (their) sticks” has been a factor for the team as a whole.
“As you start to go, ‘Don’t, don’t let it happen. Don’t let it happen. Don’t let it happen,’ That is a really, really bad head space to be in when you’re going into a National Hockey League game,” he said.
With goaltending coach Scott Murray handling most of the technical aspects of Thompson’s play, Carbery’s role is often one of reassurance.
“I just try to let him know that we’ve got your back and you’re our guy,” he said. “And that will not change based on last night or based on the next five, 10 games.”
Even if Lindgren does end up taking the net for the time being, Carbery doesn’t anticipate a permanent change in starters.
“[Thompson is] our guy, and we know how great of a goaltender he has been in the past and he can be, and so him being that person for our team and our organization will not change,” Carbery said. “It’s just about continuing to fight and continuing to work to get his game to a good spot, and that’s exactly what he’s doing.”
The Capitals will face the Boston Bruins on Saturday at 7 pm.