Logan Thompson has allowed a goal on the first shot he faced in four of his 15 starts this season: ‘You can’t script this stuff’

Logan Thompson at practice
📸: Katie Adler/RMNB

Logan Thompson was worthy of being a Vezina Trophy finalist in his first two seasons with the Washington Capitals, but the start of his 2026-27 campaign has not gone according to plan.

With the Capitals’ team defense scuffling mightily, Thompson has struggled to keep pucks out of the net early in games. Thursday’s 6-3 loss to the Buffalo Sabres was another example of that.

Thompson surrendered a goal on his opponent’s first shot for the fourth time this season — and in consecutive games. After a turnover in the neutral zone, Sabres forward Jack Quinn took a pass from Noah Ostlund, deked to the middle of the ice, and fired a shot from the slot past Thompson, who was partially screened by Capitals defenseman Jack St. Ivany.

Speaking postgame, Carbery put none of the blame on Thompson, instead chalking it up to a bad bounce that turned into a rush chance where the team gave Quinn a little bit too much space.

“At the end of the day, what’s happening, we’re trying to do the right thing, and we’re making some big mistakes,” Carbery said. “Today was a little bit unlucky. [Pierre-Luc Dubois] over-skates a puck in the neutral zone. So he’s got the puck on his stick, over-skates it, next thing you know it’s coming at us two-on-two.

“Our gap is okay, it’s not great. Cole gets picked. It’s in the back of your net, and so you’re like, ‘What just happened there?’ So you want to chalk that up to a rush chance, obviously. Could we do a better job with our gap? Yes. Do you wish [Dubois] handles that puck and it doesn’t hop over his stick? Yes. So, there, you’re down 1-0.”

The other first-shot goals came against the Penguins’ Bryan Rust on October 7, the Stars’ Joel Kiviranta on November 3, and Tampa Bay’s Sam O’Reilly on November 17. The Capitals have lost three of those four games.

Logan Thompson: Goals allowed on first shot faced (2026–27)

Date Opponent Goal Scorer Time Result
Oct. 7 Pittsburgh Bryan Rust 1:19, 1st W 5-3
Nov. 3 Dallas Joel Kiviranta 8:56, 1st L 5-6
Nov. 17 Tampa Bay Sam O’Reilly 2:11, 1st L 2-5
Nov. 19 Buffalo Jack Quinn 5:25, 1st L 3-6

But the first-shot goals aren’t just a random blip. Looking deeper, Thompson has allowed the first goal against him within the opening five shots he’s faced in 10 of his 15 starts

Logan Thompson: First goal allowed by game (2026–27)

Date Opponent Shot Number
Oct. 2 Carolina 23rd
Oct. 7 Pittsburgh 1st
Oct. 9 NY Rangers 4th
Oct. 11 Seattle 3rd
Oct. 13 Carolina 12th
Oct. 17 New Jersey 5th
Oct. 20 Los Angeles 8th
Oct. 28 Philadelphia 13th
Nov. 1 Minnesota 2nd
Nov. 3 Dallas 1st
Nov. 7 Florida 2nd
Nov. 10 Ottawa 14th
Nov. 12 New Jersey 3rd
Nov. 17 Tampa Bay 1st
Nov. 19 Buffalo 1st

Thompson has allowed a total of 15 goals within the first five shots he faced in a game, spread across those 10 starts. Thursday’s Sabres game, he surrendered three goals on five shots — his worst statistical performance of the season — getting pulled for just the third time in his Capitals career and yielding the net to Charlie Lindgren for the final 50 minutes of the game.

Logan Thompson: Goals allowed within first five shots (2026–27)

Date Opponent Goals Allowed
Oct. 7 Pittsburgh 1
Oct. 9 NY Rangers 1
Oct. 11 Seattle 1
Oct. 17 New Jersey 1
Nov. 1 Minnesota 2
Nov. 3 Dallas 1
Nov. 7 Florida 2
Nov. 12 New Jersey 1
Nov. 17 Tampa Bay 2
Nov. 19 Buffalo 3
Total 15

“He’s no different than our whole group of, he’s getting some really tough looks early in games, and they’re finding a way by him, and now he’s behind the eight ball right from the start,” Carbery said. “I feel like this has gone on the whole year, majority of the year for him. I mean, I don’t know how many first-shot goals, you can’t script this stuff. I’ve never seen a goalie of his caliber and as good as he is, and all of a sudden, it’s the first shot of the game.

“It’s a weird situation where last game, some guy’s coming down Main Street,” Carbery said. “Now, we have a say in what happens. But next thing you know, it’s in the back of the net, shot one, and his head’s spinning. So, yeah, it’s a tough stretch for our entire group, including LT.”

The bad starts have crushed the team over the last few weeks. The Capitals have surrendered the first goal in six of their last nine games and have lost five of them. This season overall, the Capitals are 2–6–0 when giving up the first goal in one of Thompson’s starts.

“The guys know the start is absolutely critical,” Carbery said.

RMNB is not associated with the Washington Capitals; Monumental Sports, the NHLPA, the NHL, or its properties. Not even a little bit.

All original content on russianmachineneverbreaks.com is licensed under Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike 4.0 International – unless otherwise stated or superseded by another license. You are free to share, copy, and remix this content so long as it is attributed, done for noncommercial purposes, and done so under a license similar to this one.

zamboni logo