Spencer Carbery diagnoses Capitals’ defensive struggles and explains what’s going wrong

Spencer Carbery talks to reporters
📸: Katie Adler/RMNB

The Washington Capitals have struggled to keep the puck out of their net early in the 2026-27 NHL season. Through 19 games, they are allowing 3.68 goals per game, the fourth-worst mark in the league. During their current three-game losing streak, they have allowed 17 goals to the New Jersey Devils and Tampa Bay Lightning.

Ahead of Washington’s latest attempt to get back on track against the Buffalo Sabres, head coach Spencer Carbery spoke with 106.7 The Fan’s Sports Junkies. During his weekly radio segment, Carbery was asked to diagnose what exactly he believes is going wrong for the Capitals in their own end, and he identified two specific areas where the team can stop leaking goals.

“When you go through all of our chances that we’re giving up, when you go through all of the goals that we’re giving up, there’s two things that stick out,” Carbery said. “One is we’re not doing nearly a good enough job protecting our net front. So those are battles. Those are competitiveness. That’s getting underneath sticks. If you look at a lot of our goals, you go like, ‘Geez, teams are scoring a lot on tips, rebounds, right at the net front.’ So we have to do a better job of that.

“The other thing is we’re giving up a lot of goals off of the rush. A lot of goals we’re giving up are coming off of – they have the puck maybe at their blue line or in their end, and then they’re skating at us, and they’re shooting in our net. That would be called a rush goal. So we’re giving up a lot of rush goals, whether it’s a two-on-one, three-on-two, or rush coverage, which we need to do a better job of. And a lot of that is coming off of turnovers and puck management.”

Carbery delved further into Washington’s seeming inability to protect the front of their own net, emphasizing that the team’s defensemen and forwards need to do a better job of establishing position and preventing opponents from getting clean looks from in tight.

Coming into this season, the Capitals were on average the heaviest and tallest team in the NHL. Given that, you’d think they’d have less trouble getting torched around their net, but Carbery added that better crease protection isn’t just about being physically bigger than your opponent.

“It’s competitiveness,” Carbery said. “It’s a little bit of technique because you have to pop a stick at a certain time when you see a shot coming. It’s a little bit of digging in, physicality. It’s a good example of, like, ‘Okay, so you’re 6-foot-5, I’m 5-foot-11. Do you automatically get to tip it in my net, or is there anything I can do even though I’m smaller? Yes, there is. And that’s where I have to dig in, use technique, take your stick away, and compete harder than you to protect that area at the net front, so I don’t just automatically go, ‘Wow, you’re bigger than me, so you automatically get to score and dunk it in my net at the net front.'”

Carbery’s evaluation of where his team is weakest defensively does also track with the numbers behind their play. At five-on-five this season, the Caps have controlled 50.2 percent of shot attempts and 51.4 percent of scoring chances, but only 47.9 percent of high-danger chances, suggesting that when they do break down in their own end, they’re bleeding the worst chances.

Some analysts have wondered whether the issue is Carbery’s use of a man-on-man defensive-zone system, given the makeup of the Capitals’ roster, which prioritizes size over shiftiness and speed. The primary question there being whether the Capitals would be more successful in a zone-look, where their players would be asked to move less in their own end and could use their long reaches to disrupt lanes.

Carbery was asked to address those specific concerns and if he has thought about making a full-scale change in system during his media availability after the team’s morning skate on Thursday.

“Those are huge, massive changes,” Carbery said. “What gives me confidence (is that) we’ve essentially played the same systematically with small little tweaks over the last four years. We’ve been successful at times. I’m not saying we’ve been world beaters. And there are times where you go, ‘You know what, we need to switch it.'”

Despite that level of awareness, it doesn’t sound like Carbery plans to hit the panic button with his systems just yet, although he isn’t entirely closing the door on the possibility.

“I believe in what we’re doing, and I think we can get there to where we can do it at a high level,” Carbery said. “Is it showing right now? No. Is it giving me concern? Yes. Do we need to help the new players that we have inside of our system get this thing dialed in and be able to execute it consistently more often? Absolutely. Do I need to challenge some of the guys that have been here and perform this structure at a high level? Yeah, they need to do a better job of it as well. And do we as coaches need to do a better job of implementing it, emphasizing it, and teaching it? Yes, we do too.

“But there is a point where it’s like, okay, we may need to completely (change things up). When you do that, you just got to be very calculated about that. You need time to work on it. You cannot flip back because now you’re waffling. Like when you commit to something, when it comes to structure, you’ve got to go all in. And there’s usually some growing pains, but you stick to it, and you go with it.”

Overall, the Capitals seem to be in an identity crisis almost 20 games into the year, which isn’t exactly unexpected after a major offseason overhaul. However, it’s an issue that Carbery believes needs to be handled quickly.

“We have to start to establish a consistent identity of what our game is going to look like night to night,” Carbery said. “We’re a quarter way through the season, and we haven’t been a great team. That’s a fact. That’s not me just giving you lip service or just hand-picking the games. Over 19 games, we’re not a great team. It’s not all doom and gloom. Can we become a good team? Yes, we can. We absolutely can. But we need to continue to focus on what we’re hanging our hat on as a team, and what it’s going to look like consistently night to night.

“What are we going to look like defensively? How do we tighten up with these things? How do we make sure it becomes ingrained in our game so we can consistently keep teams off the board or consistently keep the chances against down? I know it’s a weird answer, but I’m not as worried about our results right now. We have to have something that looks like, ‘Okay, that looked really good.’ And then tomorrow night, it’s like, ‘Okay, that looked like a good team that knew what they were doing for 60 minutes.’ If that’s making any sense.”

The Capitals will also soon be boosted by the return of two of their top defenders from injury, as Vincent Desharnais and Rasmus Sandin continue to skate at practices, wearing non-contact jerseys. Desharnais (appendectomy) has been out of the lineup since an October 20 game against the Los Angeles Kings, while Sandin (ACL surgery) has yet to make his season debut.

Washington will try to get back on track defensively and overall on Thursday night against a Buffalo team that has lost five straight. The Sabres are scoring just 2.76 goals per game, which ranks 25th in the NHL, and the Capitals already downed them 4-3 in overtime last month thanks to two goals, including the OT winner, from Alex Tuch.

RMNB is not associated with the Washington Capitals; Monumental Sports, the NHLPA, the NHL, or its properties. Not even a little bit.

All original content on russianmachineneverbreaks.com is licensed under Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike 4.0 International – unless otherwise stated or superseded by another license. You are free to share, copy, and remix this content so long as it is attributed, done for noncommercial purposes, and done so under a license similar to this one.

zamboni logo