A dispiriting loss on home ice to the Buffalo Sabres put the Washington Capitals twenty games into the regular season. Here at RMNB, twenty games is a kind of milestone. Enough hockey has been played that we can begin to evaluate the team, identify some patterns, and maybe even draw some conclusions.
Who are the Washington Capitals of 2026-27? This is my state of the union address for a team that needs a lot of improvement.
The Washington Capitals are on pace to miss the playoffs
With 20 points in 20 games, the Capitals are at .500, which would be even in a league without a loser point. In the NHL, even would be around a points percentage of .550 – and that would still miss the playoffs. They’re on pace for 84 points right now. Last season they missed the playoffs with 95 points, admittedly a rare occurrence to miss with that many points.
They’ll need 97 points this season to (virtually) guarantee a playoff spot. That is completely doable, and perhaps we’re all just reeling from a losing streak. But right now, Moneypuck has the Caps at 32 percent chance to make the postseason, HockeyViz has them much better at 65 percent, slightly ahead of Dom at The Athletic at 62 percent.
The Capitals are a mediocre possession team
During five-on-five play, it matters a lot who’s got the puck more and who does more with it when they have it. There are a few ways to measure it, and the Capitals are unremarkable in almost all of them.
| Measurement | % | Rank |
|---|---|---|
| Shot attempts | 50.1 | 16th |
| Unblocked attempts | 51.5 | 11th |
| Shots on goal | 51.3 | 14th |
In these stats, fifty percent means even: both teams take the same number of shots. Higher is better – 55 is really good, 45 is really bad.
If we plot the two halves of possession, offense and defense, separately, we see the Caps are snugly in the middle.

So by raw numbers, the Capitals are fine – neither good nor bad.
But the Capitals are losing the shot-quality war
If you weight each shot by how likely it is to become a goal (its danger, based on historical data), you get expected goals. Factoring in shot quality, as Chris said this week, a pattern emerges.
Though they possess 50.1 to 51.5 percent of attempts by raw measurements, the Capitals control just 46.4 percent of the expected goals during five-on-five play. They’re in 21st, just above the Nashville Predators.
The gap occurs at both sides of the ice, but far worse on defense. The Caps rank 23rd in limiting opponent quality per shot (i.e. expected goals divided by attempts) and 24th in limiting high-danger chances per shot (i.e. high-danger chances divided by attempts). Opponents are getting 12.1 high-danger chances against the Caps per hour, 23rd place.
For context, before the 2018 trade deadline, the defensively challenged Capitals allowed 12.9 high-danger chances per hour, 31st place.
But when I consult HockeyViz’s heatmap of Washington’s defense, it doesn’t look so dire.

Because shot quality isn’t the critical flaw.
Lately, goaltending is the Caps’ biggest problem
During five-on-five play, Logan Thompson and Charlie Lindgren combined are saving .882, or 31st place. In the month of November, they’ve allowed at least five goals in six of eight games – they lost all six and won the other two (Florida and Ottawa).

Note: Color-coding represents which goalie started the game (Lindgren in red), but not who finished it.
Out of the 65 most played goalies this season, when facing high-danger shots, Logan Thompson ranks 49th and Charlie Lindgren ranks 57th. With league-average goaltending, they’d have allowed seven fewer goals in just those cases.
With a spotty defensive corps in front of them, Thompson and Lindgren have a tough job this season, but their performance even relative to that defense is lacking.
The power play is somehow even worse than it seems
The power play is a volume game, and the Caps don’t do volume.
They’ve had 53 power-play opportunities, 31st in the league. Only the Columbus Blue Jackets, who are on pace to have 67 standings points, have fewer. The Caps are earning about one half a PP per game less than the league average and one whole opportunity less per game than the league’s best.
And when they’re actually a man up, the Caps do little with it. They generate 90 shot attempts per hour, 26th place and a 15 percent drop from last season, when they were still only middling.

Fewer opportunities and fewer shots on those opportunities is a 1-2 punch that makes the Caps’ power-play numbers look even worse than the conversion percentage, 20.8, or 18th place, makes it seem. The team is 29th in total power-play goals.
(A surprise to me was opponents’ shorthanded chances. The Caps have allowed one shorthanded goal and 1.2 expected goals. That’s not bad.)
There are reasons we could trace about why the power play is bad overall, and we’ll get into personnel soon.
The penalty kill is a minor emergency
Washington had a top five penalty kill squad just two seasons ago, but that’s long over. Killing 74 percent of shorthanded sessions this season places the Caps 22nd by rate, and that still undersells the problem.
Opponents generate 118 shot attempts per hour against the Caps PK, 29th place in the league, ahead of only San Jose, Vancouver, and Seattle – poor company. That’s the first-order problem, and the team is masking it in the obvious way: throwing their bodies in front of pucks. The Caps penalty killers step in front of 30 percent of opponent shots, more than anyone else in the league, where the average is about 25 percent.
Unlike at five-on-five, where goaltending is sinking the project, Thompson and Lindgren have been almost fine when shorthanded, saving only 0.4 goals below expected, 21st place. Last season’s Caps weren’t much better, but back then they had top-10 goaltending to hide it.
So the penalty kill’s problem is understated, systemic, unlikely to improve without intervention, and likely to get worse, causing negative externalities due to injury attrition.
Lightning round
A summary follows. The following visualization shows how the Capitals rank (percentile) in each stat.
STANDINGS Points
SHOT Attempt % (5v5)
Expected goals % (5v5)
Actual goals % (5v5)
SAVING (5v5)
Finishing (5v5)
Power play
Penalty kill
Peter’s conclusions
One thing we can all agree on is that, preseason wishes aside, the Washington Capitals are not Cup contenders. As of right now, they’re not even a playoff team.
I don’t want to overreact to the last couple weeks, but I’m worried the team will underreact. Goaltending should improve as the season goes on, simply because .878 and .864 aren’t sustainable numbers for proven players like Thompson and Lindgren. Progression to the mean in save percentage will go a long way towards bringing Washington’s standings points up, but it’d be a failure if the coaches and front office relied on that assumption.
Carbery seems to get it. “We’re a quarter way through the season, and we haven’t been a great team,” Carbery said earlier this week. “That’s a fact. That’s not me just giving you lip service or just hand-picking the games. [. . . ] Can we become a good team? Yes, we can. We absolutely can.”
A couple days later, Carbery was asked if drastic changes were on the way. His answer was curious to me.
“The only thing I can speak to is lineup changes,” Carbery said after the Buffalo game. “And that’s a valid question. We felt like today, going with the same personnel, tweaked one of the lines.”
His answer goes on, but what he did not address is most interesting.
A few days prior to that, Carbery was pressed on possible systems changes. He seemed reluctant. “Those are huge, massive changes,” Carbery said. “What gives me confidence (is that) we’ve essentially played the same systematically with small little tweaks over the last four years. We’ve been successful at times. I’m not saying we’ve been world beaters. And there are times where you go, ‘You know what, we need to switch it.'”
That switch has not happened yet, but it should.
Carbery also did not mention possible roster changes, which are the purview of the front office and general manager Chris Patrick. The team loaded up on skilled, veteran forwards over the summer – a successful project so far – but they were much shyer on defense, which seems to be hurting them now. More on that later. In part two of our Twenty Games In review, we’ll look at the individuals – who is scoring, who is struggling, and who is Alex Ovechkin?
This story would not be possible without
Please consider joining us in supporting them.

