Toronto Maple Leafs or Washington Capitals: Which losing team is sadder?

Auston Matthews and Tom Wilson
📸: Alan Dobbins/RMNB

Reeling from a five-game losing streak, the Capitals have three days of rest to ponder their struggles. They may use that time to re-evaluate personnel and tactics, to work on conditioning, or to practice the power of positive thought.

What they must not do is compare their misery to the Toronto Maple Leafs. We can do that for them. On a losing streak of their own, the Leafs may be competing for saddest team in the NHL right now. But it will be a battle.


We’ll approach this scientifically. The Leafs and Caps will go head-to-head – figuratively; they will meet next literally on December 21 – in many dimensions before we determine the winner. The winner in this case is the worse loser.

Slump severity

Toronto has not won any of their last nine games, 1-8-1 in their last ten, worst in the league, below even Detroit. The Leafs’ last win came against the Canucks on American Halloween, which might be a different date than Canadian Halloween, but it’s impossible to know for sure.

The Caps aren’t much better, 3-7-0 in their last ten games, 29th place. All three of their wins in that span were one-goal games. The Caps have allowed 49 goals in that span, most in the league. Pathetically, the Leafs have allowed a measly 38 goals. Though it’s been brutal for the Caps, they cannot stand up to the excellence of excrement that has been the Leafs of late.

Winner: Toronto 🍁 by a lot


Standings and playoff hopes

The Capitals are on pace for 80 points, the same total they had in 2022-23 before head coach Peter Laviolette was fired. Were it to continue, it would be a miserable finish to Alex Ovechkin’s career.

Heading up beyond the 49th parallel, the Leafs are on track to finish with 64 points, which would be even worse than their lottery-winning, 78-point campaign in 2025-26. If you’re sad about the Caps possibly finishing with 80 points, consider that the Leafs have done that or worse nine times during Ovechkin’s career.

Leafs 🍁 Caps 🦅
Moneypuck 1% 34%
Athletic 3% 58%
HockeyViz 4% 50%

Playing in the same division is really good for Washington, though it makes them the loser in this contest where losing is winning.

Winner: Toronto 🍁


Driving play

This part is fascinating, so just indulge me. We can use five-on-five shot-attempt percentage (SA%) – i.e. the share of shots taken by one team compared to their opponents – as a measurement of puck possession and play-driving.

Whether you measure by raw shot attempts or weighted expected goals, the results are the same: the Caps are better – 50 percent to 47 percent. But if you count only the high-danger chances, the Leafs somehow pass the Caps – 49 percent to 47 percent, underlining Washington’s shot quality problem we’ve been reporting on here for a couple weeks. There’s a lot more to get into there, but we’re trying to keep this article lighter fare.

Winner: Toronto 🍁 by a hair


Goaltending

Nice try, Leafs. Though $7 million goalie Sergei Bobrovsky has had a tough month, allowing five goals more than expected, backup Anthony Stolarz has been fine.

Amateur hour compared to Washington’s duo. Charlie Lindgren has allowed 16 goals versus nine expected, and Logan Thompson has allowed 24 versus 17. Folks, that’s 14 goals worse than a league average goalie would have done in just nine games. With an .805 save percentage, the Caps have the worst goaltending in the league. They have lapped the field, leaving the Leafs in the dust.

Winner: Washington 🦅 in a rout


Special teams

Led by Auston Matthews with five power-play goals, the Leafs are #ActuallyRespectable when up a man, sporting a 25.7 percent conversion rate, 7th best in the league. The Caps’ PP has been rebounding of late, scoring five PPGs in their last five games. With a 22.8 percent, they’re in 15th place. Boring.

On the penalty kill, the Leafs are again a top-ten team, killing 82.1 percent for 7th place again. That’s where the Caps are flailing, 21st place with a 73.9. They’ve allowed a power-play goal in eight of their last ten games. They are victorious in their defeat.

Winner: Washington 🦅


Star power

Auston Matthews and William Nylander earn almost $25 million between them. They need to be good, and they have been, staying near previous season’s individual goal and point paces.

In Washington, last season’s goal leader has one goal this time around. And it came more than a month ago. Instead, the Caps have been relying on Alex Tuch, both their biggest earner and scorer. With 14 goals, Tuch is tied with Matthews, but it’s lonely at the top. Tuch has just two assists to Matthews’ 15.

Toronto has way more star power, and therefore they lose.

Winner: Washington 🦅 decisively


The youths

Gavin McKenna was the first overall draft pick in 2026, but I think Easton Cowan, drafted late in the first round of 2023, has been the better player. He had 14 points in the first 16 games through the end of October, and then he hit a wall, putting a bunch of zeroes and negative goal differentials during Toronto’s slump. McKenna has been no better in the last few weeks.

The Caps have three fun, young players. Cole Hutson and Ryan Leonard have been some of Washington’s best players during the slump. Leonard has the most goals among the young’ns on either team, and Hutson is third in points despite being a defender.

Ilya Protas is also young, but I don’t want to talk about him. For now, Washington’s youth has been better, which makes them the losers.

Winner: Toronto 🍁


Coach charisma

During the Bruins game, I saw someone behind the Caps bench hold up a sign that said, “best dressed coach in the NHL.” Fair, fair. Spencer Carbery cuts a fine figure, and he knows what to say when his team is losing.

Here’s a clear, concise description of what’s been going wrong, according to the HC:

One is we’re not doing nearly a good enough job protecting our net front. So those are battles. Those are competitiveness. That’s getting underneath sticks. If you look at a lot of our goals, you go like, ‘Geez, teams are scoring a lot on tips, rebounds, right at the net front.’ So we have to do a better job of that.

The other thing is we’re giving up a lot of goals off of the rush. A lot of goals we’re giving up are coming off of – they have the puck maybe at their blue line or in their end, and then they’re skating at us, and they’re shooting in our net. That would be called a rush goal. So we’re giving up a lot of rush goals, whether it’s a two-on-one, three-on-two, or rush coverage, which we need to do a better job of. And a lot of that is coming off of turnovers and puck management.

Whether or not he will or is even empowered to do something about it, I think Carbery understands his team.

After a loss on the 18th, Toronto head coach Jim Hiller said, “We’ve kind of given some guys some rope and let them run with it a little bit…” and then he trailed off.

On Saturday, I worried for his object permanence and dysphagia. “We’ve had stretches and it gets you excited because you can see what you can do and for whatever reason we have moments like you see tonight… It’s not National Hockey League level… It’s frustrating for all of us… It’s hard to swallow.”

During that game, a 4-3 loss to Columbus, Toronto fans chanted for Hiller to be fired. “The noise is the noise,” Hiller said fettermanly. “And it’s always going to be there. I understand that. We’ve got to do some soul-searching here.”

Feels like they’re about to do some coach-searching too.

Winner: Toronto 🍁 for now


Usually pollyanna-ish independent media

In the DC region, I’ve been whinging and musing on the nature of sadness. Chris has been pleading for change in NFTMAs for a month. Ian’s been looking on the bright side on the site and being cryptic on Twitter. Katie’s been steadfastly reporting the perspectives in the locker room.

And in Toronto, from a man who has written two books about his allegiance to the Maple Leafs, this:

We can’t compete with that level of venom.

Winner: Toronto 🍁. Bravo, Steve. Damn.


To the surprise of several, perhaps even dozens, the Toronto Maple Leafs are worse, sadder, and more pitiable than the Washington Capitals. Congratulations to the winners.

The Leafs will visit the 11-6-5 Islanders on Monday. The Caps are off until Wednesday, when they’ll host the Flyers. Winnable.

RMNB is not associated with the Washington Capitals; Monumental Sports, the NHLPA, the NHL, or its properties. Not even a little bit.

All original content on russianmachineneverbreaks.com is licensed under Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike 4.0 International – unless otherwise stated or superseded by another license. You are free to share, copy, and remix this content so long as it is attributed, done for noncommercial purposes, and done so under a license similar to this one.

zamboni logo