Mentorship down: Caps lose to Lightning for third L in a row

WSH @ TBL
📸: William B.

The Washington Capitals disappointed again in a punishing road loss to the Tampa Bay Lightning. Haven’t seen someone let down a Mentor like that since Telemachus wandered off to Sparta.

Sam O’Reilly came out of nowhere to beat Logan Thompson just two minutes into the game. Halfway into the first period, defender Charle-Edouard D’Astous (and I think that name is probably Polish) scored off a pass from defender John Carlson, who himself got a pass from a third defender, Ryan McDonagh. Jake Guentzel scored on a too-easy rebound. The score was 3-0 just 15 minutes into regulation. Aliaksei Protas sent a centering pass to Alex Tuch to save face before the first period was up.

Jake Guentzel owned the only goal of the middle period, tipping in a big shot by John Carlson. In the third, Ryan Leonard brought the Caps within two goals, but Anthony Cirelli sent a very long shot into an empty net.

Lightning beat Caps 5-2.

Get RMNB ad-free

Support us on Patreon for $5 to hide all ads and get other perks

More Info

  • The Caps have allowed five, seven, and five goals in their last three games. They have zero shutouts and have held opponents to one goal just once.
  • Congratulations to 20-year-old Sam O’Reilly, who scored his first NHL goal in just his fourth NHL game.
  • But given how Logan Thompson is playing lately, I think I could have beaten him tonight too. LT allowed three goals on the first six shots he faced. Considering how the Caps are playing defensively, Thompson has a tougher job than two-thirds of the league, but even relative to that he’s struggling. I’m surprised he stayed in the game. Maybe Spencer Carbery is as worried about Thompson’s confidence as the rest of us.
  • Cole Hutson is a talented young player, but still: he choked on the first Guentzel goal. LT couldn’t have been happy about that.
  • Alex Tuch scored his 12th goal of the season, meaning he now has 1100% more goals than Alex Ovechkin, who is either cursed or cooked.
  • Matt Roy leveled a big hit on Zemgus Girgensons to help make that Tuch goal happen. He’s putting together another solid if understated season.
  • Down three goals in the second period and the Caps could still only put five shots on net. One span between shots was nearly fourteen minutes long. Abysmal hockey. I am sorry to our friends who attended.
  • The Lightning gave Ovechkin a nice nod and a pregame gift of cigars. I went to Cuba a few years ago, and I smoked a whole cigar, and then I got super sick and had to leave a jazz show early and then couldn’t leave my room for the whole next day, and then I didn’t realize you’re not allowed to bring cigars back to the US because I thought I saw a video where Arnold Schwarzenegger said it was okay, but I guess the Terminator lied? Ovi had one shot on goal.
  • The D’Astous goal was a weird one: scored by a defender and assisted by two other defenders. I bet that is rare. Someone who isn’t on a deadline: please plug that into the ol’ Postgres DB and let us know the last time a goal gave points to three different defenders. One of those defenders was ex-Cap legend John Carlson. Apparently he’s still friendly with his old teammates, but I hear it’s not quite the same situation with the front office.
  • Jakob Chychrun‘s dad Jeff gave an extensive interview with ESPN during the second period. He seems like a sweet guy, and maybe it was a kindness to be distracted from that wretched stretch of hockey, but that was a bit indulgent.

This is not our beautiful boys

— Good Skeet Pete (@peterhassett.net) 2026-11-18T00:32:22.706Z

Having lost three in a row, the Caps are now on pace to miss the playoffs. It’s still early days, but the 20-game threshold comes after the Buffalo game on Thursday, after which point I’m going to say some really mean things like, “hey, maybe player X shouldn’t be on the team,” and “hey, maybe player Y shouldn’t be on the team,” and “hey, maybe head coach Z should change the defensive scheme.” But I’m not ready to name names just yet.

The way I hear it – anyone can beat the Buffalo Sabres lately. The Caps could do it too. Stranger things have happened.

RMNB is not associated with the Washington Capitals; Monumental Sports, the NHLPA, the NHL, or its properties. Not even a little bit.

All original content on russianmachineneverbreaks.com is licensed under Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike 4.0 International – unless otherwise stated or superseded by another license. You are free to share, copy, and remix this content so long as it is attributed, done for noncommercial purposes, and done so under a license similar to this one.

zamboni logo