The Pittsburgh Penguins are quickly approaching a major turning point as their disappointing start to the 2026-27 NHL season has put the future of the franchise’s longtime core into question.
After surprisingly making the playoffs last spring, the Penguins entered this season hoping to remain competitive. Instead, they’ve fallen to the bottom of the NHL standings with their 7-11-2 record, forcing general manager Kyle Dubas to confront the possibility that the organization needs to shift its focus toward the future.
Dubas spoke with reporters Wednesday at the team’s 20-game mark and made it clear that significant roster changes will be coming if Pittsburgh can’t turn things around.
“If we carry on in this way, I think the types of transactions you’ll see from us will be very future-oriented,” Dubas said.
In other words, the Penguins will likely become sellers soon. Many of the players who helped the organization win three Stanley Cups over the past two decades are now in the latter stages of their careers, and the team hasn’t gotten the consistent production it needs from that veteran core.
The prime example is captain Sidney Crosby, who has just 13 points (6g, 7a) and a minus-7 rating in 20 games. They’ve also managed only 18 combined points from projected top-six forwards Andrei Kuzmenko, Egor Chinakhov, and Rickard Rakell, on top of prolonged injury issues for high-scoring winger Bryan Rust.
“We’ve shown flashes of playing very good hockey,” Dubas said. “But they’ve been that: flashes. We’ve been generally inconsistent and had long stretches of play where we haven’t been at our best and [haven’t represented] what we want to be about.”
Dubas acknowledged that the current situation was something he anticipated when he took over in Pittsburgh. The organization has tried to extend its competitive window rather than fully commit to a rebuild, but there are limitations to how long it can continue relying on the same group of players.
“When I came here, I knew we would likely confront this,” Dubas said. “We’ve openly endeavored to not have prolonged stretches like this. But with the core group, you can only squeeze so much out of them.”
As hockey insider Darren Dreger previously reported, Pittsburgh has already been listening to trade offers for several veterans, including Rust, Rakell, and defensemen Erik Karlsson and Kris Letang. With the club’s season unraveling further, attention could now even turn to franchise legends like Crosby and Evgeni Malkin.
Malkin, 40, is playing on a one-year contract that expires after this season. According to PuckPedia, the veteran center must submit a list of three teams he’d be willing to be traded to at an unidentified date in January. The Russian forward has teased that this year could be his last in the NHL, so Pittsburgh may want to capitalize on the value he still holds after posting 17 points (6g, 11a) in his first 18 games this season.
Crosby, 39, is also in the final season of his current contract. His agent, Pat Brisson, and Dubas have yet to negotiate an extension, although the longtime captain has repeatedly expressed that he doesn’t want to play for another NHL organization. When asked about Crosby’s future, Dubas emphasized that the Penguins want to allow their captain to decide what comes next.
“In Sid’s case, he’s as unique as it gets,” Dubas said. “I would just go back to my view on it from the opening of the season, is that we want to get into this as far as we can, have an indication about where we’re at and where we’re going, and make sure everyone’s comfortable with that. And then, he’s owed all the respect in the world. If he wants to be here, that’s great, and that’s obviously what we would love as well.”
Given Crosby’s stated past desires, the Penguins are unlikely ever to trade the legendary centerman, leaving him with three options: retire after this season, sign an extension with Pittsburgh, or sign with one of the other 31 NHL teams in free agency next summer. Crosby will see his longtime rival and friend, Washington Capitals captain Alex Ovechkin, retire after 22 seasons in the league once the 2026-27 campaign ends.
Beyond the more obvious names like Malkin, Karlsson, Letang, Rust, Rakell, and Kuzmenko, the Penguins could also try to find new homes for depth pieces like Justin Brazeau, Samuel Girard, and Spencer Stastney, all of whom are scheduled to become unrestricted free agents in July.